ITL, chapter 6

Chapter 6, Tort Law

Chapter 6, Tort Law


C. H.
This flashcard set delves into the intricacies of liability and damage within the realm of tort law, tailored for university-level students. It explores various aspects such as liability for one's own fault, vicarious liability, and strict liability, using case studies like the Cellar Hatch Case to illustrate key concepts. The set also discusses the differences between fault liability and strict liability, and the principles of tort law, including the determination of duty of care and the grounds for a tortfeasor to pay for damages. This comprehensive collection is invaluable for law students seeking to understand the nuances of liability and damage in civil and common law approaches.
Flashcards
12
Students
1
Language
English
Category
Law
Level
University
Created / Updated
25.09.2014 / 29.09.2014

Flashcards

What are the main principles of Tort Law ? (3)

1) Everyone must in principle bears his own damages.

2) It does not focuses on punishment but on compensation.

3) It does not deals with damages that resulted from nonperformance of a contract.

What are the two kind of liability ?

Fault liability and strict liability.

What is the difference between fault liability and strict liability ?

-Fault liability, a wrongful act for which the agent can be blamed for it and must compensate.

-Strict liability, the risk that something who belongs to you causes damages and so you must compensate for it.

Why do we have strict liability ?

1) For fairness

2) Economic efficiency

3) Possibility to recover 

4) Prevention of damages

What are the grounds of a tortfeasor has to pay for the victims' damages?

1) cases in which a tortfeasor acted wrongfully and has to compensate for the damages that resulted from his wrongful behaviour. (Liability for one's own fault)

2) cases in which someone is liable for the damage that was wrongfully caused by a tortfeasor ( liability for a tortfeasor 's fault)

3) cases in which a tortfeasor is liable for the damage caused by an animal or by an object for which he is responsible (strict liability)

Liability for one's own fault in the common law approach, when behaviour is unlawful ?

1) There must have been a duty of care

2) This duty was breached

3) Damages resulted

4) It is a damage for which the tortfeasor is directly responsible

Behaviour is unlawful when there is a breach in a duty of care.

How can we know if there is a duty of care in the common law?

Through the Learned Hand Formula, we can determine if there is liability.

If the probability be called P, the injury L, and the burden B,

Liability depends upon whether B is less likely than PxL 

B < PxL

Liability for one's own fault in the civil law approach, what are the conditions for liability?

1) there must have been an act or omission that unlawfully violated a legally protected interest

2) the unlawful act or omission must have caused damage of a type that qualifies for compensation.

The tort fearsome is blameworthy, unlawful behaviour.

What can we take off of the Cellar Hatch Case ?

Some circumstances can require special precautionary measures because individuals cannot always be expected to pay sufficient attention to their environment and circumstances.

Which factors should be taken into account ?

1) the degree of probability that the required attention and care would be disregarded,

2) the degree of likelihood that this might lead to an accident,

3) the gravity of the consequences of such accidents,

4) the burden of adequate precautions.

What is the difference between Ex Post and Ex Ante ?

in the civil law.

Ex Post : For this particular case, this determination is done after the damage and only with an eye to the damages as they actually occurs, the law focuses only on the best allocation of existing damages

Ex Ante : this determination is formulated with an eye to future cases, the law focuses onnthe best allocation of existing damages but also on the prevention or minimization of future damages.

Explain liability for damage caused by other person ? (3)

1) Vicarious liability :employers are under certain circumstances liable for their employees' damages.

2) Special relation to the tortfeasor (parents-children)

3) Deep Pocket Theory (place the liability where the money is)

Explain Traffic Liability .

In the event of a collision with pedestrians or bicyclists, the owner/keeper is liable unless he can persuade the court that it was a case of force-majeure.

The Loi Badinter : French law. no force majeure defence. The only defense is contributory negligence, it is inexcusable (eg suicide)

Study