ITL, chapter 2
Chapter 2, Sources of Law
Chapter 2, Sources of Law
-
- 1 / 16
-
Lernkarten
What is a source of law?
Standards that determine if a rule has the statue of law.
What is sources of origin?
Represent ways in which the law has came into existence, they have no relevancy on the content of the law.
What is sources of validity?
Rules that have been created by persons or institutions who have the power to do so.
When do social rules exist?
If the member of this group tend to follow the rule, and if they see a violation of this rule as a reason for (self) criticism, and if they believe that the other members of the group do the same.
they can only exist if they are effective.
Explain the Sources Thesis.
All legal rules are institutional rules.
so, only rules that stem from a validity source, and which are therefor institutional rules, would be lega rules.
this means that the court that is to apply the law should only consult validity sources, such as legislation, case law, treaties, to find legal rules.
What is Trias Politica?
The division of the power among three different institutions.
The Judicial, the Executive, the Legislative.
Mention three general principles that govern the conflict of rules.
1) Lex Superior (the superior rules precedes over the inferior rule)
2) Lex Specialis (the more specific rule prevails over the more general rule)
3) Lex Posterior (newer rule prevails over the older one)
What is wrong with the Westphalian conception of treaties ?
Treaties will normally deal with international relations, or at least, cases that are not limited to national borders.
Treaties belong to transnational laws, and those laws do not belong to the Westphalian duo.
What is Ratio Dicidendi ?
The decisive grounds that made the court take the decision.
What is Obiter Dicta ?
Other reasons than the principal that made the court take the decision, which are relevant but did not determine the court's decision.
What are the condition of existence for customary law ?
1) there must be a custom conserving an effective guideline for behaviour. This is called the Usus.
2) That custom must be accepted as binding one or as legal one.
The view that the custom is law, Opinio Iuris
The view that the custom is binding and necessary, Opinio Necessitatis
What are in the common law tradition the relation between the Ratio Dicidendi of a case, broadening and distinguishing?
The Ratio Dicidendi consists of the decisive grounds that made the court take the decision.
Distinguishing: The binding nature of precedent only applies to future cases that are similar to the already decided case. By pointing out relevant differences (=distinguishing) , the court can argue that the cases are not similar and that it is not bound by a particular precedent.
Broadening, it is possible that a court treats cases as similar when their similarity was not obvious.
In common law, what are the source of origin ?
1) customary law
2) legal doctrine
3) reason
In common law, what are the sources if validity ?
1) case law
2) legislation
3) treaties
In civil law, what are the sources of origin ?
1) customary law
2) legal doctrine
3) reason
4) case law
In civil law, what are the sources of validity ?
1) legislation
2) treaties