Contract Law
contract law-offer and acceptance
contract law-offer and acceptance
-
- 1 / 61
-
Cartes-fiches
There is an exception to this general rule that communication needs to be communicated to the offeror, theses excaptions are?
- in unilateral contracts, there is an implied wavier to the commmunication requirment, as the performance of the Act constitutes acceptance. the Case for this is Carlil.
- Acceptance by post when the parties are not in each otheres presence.
Can acceptance happen through conduct?
yes it can, the legal authority for this is:
Brogden v Metropolitan Railway Co. 1877
Case facts of Brogden v Metropolitan Railwan Co. 1877 are?
- Brogden coal suppliers had been supplying coal to the railway for quiet some time without a writen contract.
- they decided to draw up a written contract so the railway company wrote a draf and sent it to brogden
- brogden made some changes to the terms and sent it back to the railway(defendant)
- they filled the document and didn't write back.
It was held that as performance of the contract continues it stipulated acceptance therefore there was a valid contract despite not communicationg back
Just because unilateral contracts can waive the need for communicating acceptance, it does not mean that in bilateral contracts this is the same?
In Bilateral contracts silence will not constitute acceptance. the legal authority for this is
Felthouse v Blindley 1862
- a case involving a nephew trying to purchase a horse from his uncle, he said if i dont hear from you by the weekend i will assume the horse is mine, the auctioneer accidently sold the horse even when the nephew told him not to.
The courts held there was no claim as silence did not become acceptance.
can acceptance be communicated by post?
yes it can and the legal authrity for this is
adam v lindsel 181
case facts of adam v lidsel 1818 is?
- defendant wrote to the claimant offering to sell wool
- the claimant recieved the letter late as it was misdirected
- due to this the claimant reply through the letter was delay and because of this the defendant sold the wool to someone else.
Courts held: as soon as the letter was posted a valid contract came into existance.
This case set out the postal rule
Another case involving the postel rule that gives a modern take on it is?
Household insurance v Grant 1879
- involved grant applied for shares
- he was alloted the shares and was posted a letter containing notice of allotment
- grant never recieves the letter, the insurance compay goes bankrupt and asks grant for the payment of shares, he refuses.
Theisger Lj held that there was a valid contract, as the postal rule is when the letter is posted acceptance exists, even if the letter never arrives. However he also states that anyone can opt out of the postal rule.
What are the justification for the postal rule?
The justification is demonstrated through
Henthorn v Fraser 1892 case:
A case involving the selling of a property which after being accepted via post was sold by the defendant to a third party. It was held that the contract had been formed.
it is argues that if the offeror allows use of post as an acceptance then it is offeror who should bare the risks as they can choose not to.
The postal rule can be avoided if the offeror indicates that another means of acceptance is required, this is demonstrated in?
Holwell securties ltd v Hughes 1974
this case concerned an option to buy some land. An option is basically an offer. The plaintiff accepted this offer by post, which did not arrive at the defendants given address. Defendant had asked for “notice to be in writing”.
CA held that the word “notice” indicated that actual communication of acceptance was required and this was enough to displace the postal rule.
what is exception to when silence can amout to an acceptance in bilateral contracts?
In Re Selectmove 1995 the CA held that if offeree states that silence could be a sufficient acceptance, only then could amount to a valid acceptance
however there is no clear rule on this.
apart from the exception of postal rule, all other forms of acceptance have to be communicated to the offeror, what are these other methods of communication?
Instantaneous communication, which are telephone, e-mail,fax
what are the legal autoritys for instataneous communication?
Entores ltd v Miles far east corporation 1955-involved a dutch and english company, where dutch company sent a telex to the english company with an offer, the english company sent a counter offer, the dutch accepted the counter offer.
The question was were did the contract form, the CA held that the contract was formed in England once they had recieved the acceptance.
Brinkbon v Stahag Stahl 1983- lord wilberforce held that no rulecould cover such cases, however a general principle coud be identified, if the offeree has done all that he can to communicate acceptance, that acceptance should take effect when the offeree thinks it would reasonably be recieved by the offeror
The brimes 1975 demonstrates that ordinary business hours can be assumed to be within 5:30-18:00 however if you are aware of the offic hours then it is different.
How can offers terminate?
- lapse of time
- death
- rejection
lapse of time is?
when there is particular time given to when the offer will end, there is usually a period in which an offer must be accepted.
Ramsgate Victoria Hotel v Montefiore 1866- case regarding offer to buy shares in june, the acceptance of the shares happened in november. the defendant refused to pay for the shares.
The court held that acceptance was not made within a reasonable time.
Death general is?
- if the offeror has offered to perform services that require their expertise then the death of the offeror will terminate the offer.
- if the offer is about something else for e.g. the supply of goods, if the offeree id notified about death before acceptance then the offer would terminate, if not then the deceased estates may be bound.
However ther is no particular ruling about this.
rejection
a offer can be rejected by counter offer hyde v wrench 1840
what is revocation?
offeror may revoke an offer anytime before acceptance.Revocation has to be communicated, postal rule does not apply,
in communication the key thing is time:
in Bryne v Van Tienhoven 1880- a letter of revocation had been posted, then after a while a letter of acceptance had been posted, as the revocation letter had not arrived before the acceptance had happened, the revocation was ineffective.
Henthorn v Fraser 1892- regarding buying property
is a firm offer promise revocable?
Routledge v Grant 1828-offer was open for 6 weeks, after 3 week defendant withdrew offer. Courts held that in the absence of consideration to support the promise, the offer could be withdrawn.
what is the function of a unilateral contract?
it is a promise to reward a party if they perform a specific act
carlil v carbolic smoke ball co.
What are the two types of unilateral offer?
- to individuals- Greath Nothern Rainway co v witham
- to a larger public- carlil v carbolic smoke ball co.
what are the rules of unilateral acceptance?
- communication is not required
- performance will constitute consideration for the promise made by offeror
- person performing the act needs to know about the award in order for the other party to be bound
how can unilateral offers be revocated?
there have been many difficulties in this area as acceptance is communicated by performance.
Most recent case that demontrates this issue is
salsbury v salsbury 2007
reward of money was offered to an ex wifeafter death of ex husband if she refrain from taking out a court order in her favour. it was held as soon as promise was acted upon it could no loger be revocated.