Contract Law
contract law-offer and acceptance
contract law-offer and acceptance
-
- 1 / 61
-
Lernkarten
The first step to determine whether a contract has been formed is?
By identifying whethere an agreement had been formed.
An agreement is determined by?
An objective test
What does an objective test mean?
It means that the court looks at external evidence to see whether there was an agreement, by looking at what the parties said and did during the supposed time of contract
What is an objective test?
is when you look at what a reasonable man would say, and whethere they agreed that there was an obvious contractual agreement.
Why is an objective approach better then a subjective approach?
A subjective approach creates uncertainty and it would be impractical as the person making the promise could later go back on their word.
What is the difference between an offer and negotiations?
An offer is the willingness to contract on the specified terms without any further negotiations, so that it only requires acceptance for a binding agreement to be formed.
To determine the difference between offer and negotiation, what test is applied?
Objective test
Another important factor that is looked at to determine whether it is an offer or not, is?
the language used
The authority for this principle of looking at the language, is?
Gibson v Manchester City Council 1979
The facts of Gibson v Manchester city council are?
- Council wrote letter to tenant saying that it may be prepared to sell house at certain price
- tenant filled in application and returned it
- council changed the policy
What was held in the Gibson v Manchester City Council 1979 case?
In the CA Lord Denning held that there was a contract, he stated, "look at the correspondence as a whole and at the conduct of the parties and see there from whether the parties have come to an agreement on everything that was material."
The Coucinl appealed and then the House of Lords HELD:
that "may be prepared to sell" did not constitute an offer, rather it was inviting Mr Gibson to make an offer.
What is an invitation to treat?
stages of negotiations that do not amount an offer
In the general rule of Invitation to Treat what things are included?
advertisements, brochures and price lists
The legal authorities for the general rule are?
Patridge v Crittenden 1968 and Fisher v Bell 1961
Patridge v Crittenden 1968 case facts are?
- it was an advertisement
- to sell wild birds
- which was offence
- it did have a price
- but no quantity or delivery details
It was held in the Patridge v Critteden 1968 case?
that the advertisement did not amount to an offer, it was merely an invitation to treat.
This outcome was applied by treating these advetisment with "business sense" and "limited stock argument"
Fisher v Bell 1961 case facts?
- a flick knife was displayed in the shop window with a price tag
- held that it was not an offer ans diplays on a shop window do not amount to an offer
There is an exception to this general of invitation to treat, which is?
- where the advertisment is unilateral, meaning if a reward is advertised for performing a specific act then it amounts to a unilateral offer
The legal authority for this exception are?
- Carlil v Carbolic smoke Ball co. 1893
- Lefkowitz v Great Minneapolis Surplus Store 1957
Carlil v Carbolic smoke Ball co. 1893 case facts?
- an advertisment which stated that a reward of a sum of money would be given to anyone who did not recover from influenza after using there remedy at the prescribed times.
- The CA held that: the advertisement was an offer, as it asked for a performance of an act which would constitute an acceptance.
- It was also stated that the deposited money indicated willingness to be bound by the terms of the advertisment.
In Leftkowitz v Great Minneapolis Surplus Store 1957 it was held?
That if an advertisement is to constitute an offer then it must be clear and definite in its terms and leave no room for negotiations
Shop displays and supermarket shelves are?
Invitation to treat
The legal authority for this principle is?
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemist ltd 1953
Case facts of Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemist 1953 are?
- Boots was a self service store
- it was a legal requirment for certain drugs to be sold under supervision of a pharmacist.
It was held that display of goods on shop shelves did not constitute an offer but an invitation to treat, so there was supervision at the point of sale.
This is supported by the argument that shopkeepers should have the freedom of contract and practical difficulties of shopper changing their mind.
Tenders are?
Generally Invitation to treat and the legal authority for this is Spencer v Harding
Spencer v Harding case facts 1870 are?
- circular inviting tenders
- claimant submitted hightest tender
- the defendant refused
Held that unless it is stated that tender will go to the highest tender then a teder is merely an invitation to treat.
There is a an exception to this general rule about tenders, which is?
- if there is a promise to accept the most competitive bid i.e. highest or lowest
- or if there is a contractual obligation to consider tenders which conform to the bid conditions
Promise to accept most competitive bid, legal authourity is?
Harvela- promise to accept highest bid, and asked for other requirments, two tenders were submitted, one with a price, and one with a price and refrential bid
HL Held: that referential bids would not be accepted.
legal authourity for contractual obligiation to consider a tender is?
Blackpool and Flyde Aero Club v Blackpool Borough Council 1990
- council invited tender bids that would be considered until a certain time limit.
- council did not collect the bid during the closing time.
- the club claimed council was in breach
The CA held that there was an implied unilateral offer meaning promise
Websites are?
Invitation to treat, the offer is made when the customer is at the checkout stage.
Auctions are?
General rule is that each bid is an offer and the hammer is acceptance. According to The Sales of Goods Act 1979 s57(2)
legal authourity is Payne v Cave 1789 where he made an offer and then withdrew it before the hammer went down.
The courts held that Mr Cave bid was an offer and he was entitled to withdraw it.
The exception to the general rule of auctions is?
If the auction is without reserve it constitutes a unilateral offer (a promise) which is accepted by the highest bidder, if the items are without a price then the auctioneer can not later on withdrew the items or refuse to give it to the highest bidder, or allow a vendor to bid.
The legal authorities are
Warlow v Harrison 1859- the owner had bid for his own property which he got as he was the higest bidder, but another bidder made a claim against the auctioneer for acting as an agent. The courts held that there was no claim as there was no agency relationship with the owners
Barry v Davies 2000 washing machines bidding, held that the auctioneer could not withraw the items.
Acceptance can happen when?
when the acceptance is a mirror image to the terms of the offer
The difference between Counter offer and request for more information is?
counter offer- is when the offeree tries changing the terms of the original offer and therefore coming up with new terms, this rejects the original offer so it can no loger be accepted.
request for more information- is just clarifying and getting more details about the terms of the offer.
Legal authority for counter offer is?
Hyde v Wrench 1840- offer to sell land for a certain amount, offeree repied back with a different amount.
Held that there was no contract as the original offer got destroyed so the offeree did not except anything.
legal authority for request for further informartion is ?
Stevenson, Jacques an Co. v Mclean 1880- defendant offered iron at a certain price,the plaintiff replied to the defendants offer asking about delivery period. It was held that this was an inquiry not rejection to the offer important thing to remember in this case is that the offer did not clearly state this information.
An important case which illustrates the battle of form princple and that the last shot prevails,regarding counter offer and acceptance is?
Butler Machine Tool Co. ltd v Ex Cell- O corporation 1979
Case Facts of Butler Machine Tools Co.ltd v Ex Cell-O Corporation 1979?
- Ex cell- O wanted to buy a Machine from Mr Butler
- Mr Butler sent a quotation price and terms of the offer
- Ex Cell-O put in an order and sent an acknolgment slip with it which needed signature of Mr Butler
- On the slip there were also new terms that Ex Cell-O had put in
- Mr Butler signed the slip
Mr Butler claimed that his terms were still part of the contract.
What was held in the Butler Machine case?
Lawton and Bridge Ljj held that the buyers order was a counter offer which the sellers had accepted by completing and returning the acknowledgement
What is needed for a valid acceptance?
- acceptance must be communicated to the offeree
- terms of acceptance should exactly match terms of offer
- agreement must be certain