New York Practice - Mnemonics
Mnemonics from NYP
Mnemonics from NYP
Lernkarteien erstellen oder kopieren
Mit einem Upgrade kannst du unlimitiert Lernkarteien erstellen oder kopieren und viele Zusatzfunktionen mehr nutzen.
A DIMPLE FIB
A 1 Year SOL is A DIMPLE FIB
A - ARBITRATION AWARDS must be confirmed by a special proceeding commenced in the NY Supreme Court within one year from the arbitrators award.
D - a defendant has one year to open a DEFAULT JUDGMENTS from the time the defendant was served with a copy of the default judgment
I - to recover excess INTEREST that was paid on an usury loan, which for an individual in NY is an annual interest rate exceeding 16%
M - a claim for MALICIOUS prosecution
P - the right to PUBLICITY, aka the right to PRIVACY, which claim is based on the defendants unauthorized commercial use of a living plaintiffs name, picture, or voice for advertising purposes without the plaintiffs written consent
L - LIBEL and slander
E - retaliatory EVICTION
F - FALSE arrest or FALSE imprisonment
I - INTENTIONAL INFLICTION of emotional harm
B - BATTERY or assault
CLAMS
In slander cases, the plaintiff must plead and prove damages, unless the defamatory material falls within the area of slander per so, where damages are assumed, CLAMS.
C - a false statement that the plaintiff committed a serious CRIME
L - the plaintiff has a current LOATHSOME disease
A - the statement ADVERSELY reflects on the plaintiff's profession, business or trade
M - a false statement that the plaintiff engaged in MORAL turpitude
S - the plaintiff engaged in SERIOUS SEXUAL misconduct
AID
In any Article 78 proceeding, court permission is required whenever the petition seeks AID:
A - to takes an immediate APPEAL of the courts order (CPLR 408)
I - a defendant cannot IMPLEAD a third party into the special proceeding without court permissions (CPLR 401)
D - no pretrial DISCOVERY in a special proceeding, except for notices to submit and bill of particulars, which can be used without court order.
LEAP DADS CAT
If the SOL has expired, then the plaintiff should consider NY's tolling and extending provisions, LEAP DADS CAT
L - LENGTHENING the SOL (GOL 17-103)
E - EQUITABLE ESTOPPEL, stopping the defendant from pleading the SOL
A - a written ACKNOWLEDGEMENT of an old debt
P - PART PAYMENT
D - a plaintiff under a DISABILITY
A - AMENDING pleas under the relation back doctrine (CPLR 203(f)) to add related claims or new partied after the SOL has expired
D - DEATH
S - SERVICE members civil relief act
C - COUNTERCLAIMS (CPLR 203)
A - causes of ACTION ARISING outside of NY (CPLR 207)
T - TERMINATION of a TIMELY action after the SOL has expired
ANT
If the day before the SOL expired the plaintiff timely commenced the lawsuit, but weeks/months/years later makes a motion to amend the complaint to add a new claim against the defendant that is now barred by the SOL, then that new claim is nevertheless timely provided ANT:
A - the new claim AROSE out of the transaction pleaded in the plaintiffs original complaint, that is, it is a 'related' claim;
N - the original complaint gave the defendant NOTICE of the new claims, that is the new claim is based on facts pleaded in the original complaint; and
T - the new claim was TIMELY when the plaintiff first commenced the action against the defendant, that is, it was timely on the date process was filed with the county clerk
POOPE
Parties united in interest frequently involve a vicarious relationship of POOPE parties.
P - PARTNERS who are jointly and severally libel for each others torts, PARTNERSHIPS, and breaches of contracts
O - under VTL 388, a NY vehicle OWNER is vicariously liable for the driver's negligence, provided the vehicle was being used with the owners expressed or implied consent.
O - joint OWNERS if realty are jointly and severally liable for unsafe conditions on the realty
P - PRINCIPAL and agent
E - EMPLOYER and EMPLOYEE
JPMD
The 6 month allowance cannot be used if the first action was terminated because of JPMD.
J - failure to obtain MOP JURISDICTION over the defendant
P - the first claim was dismissed because the PLAINTIFF failed to PROSECUTE, provided the courts order expressly sets forth the plaintiff's conduct constituting the neglect and that conduct must indicate a "general pattern of delay"
M - a dismissal on the MERITS
D - plaintiffs voluntary DISCONTINUANCE of the first action
TLC
Venue is chosen according to the type of action involved. TLC action can either be:
T - TRANSITORY
L - LOCAL
C - and action to recover a CHATTEL (replevin)
WASP MEN
Examples of local actions are WASP MEN
W - the tort of WASTE
A - a tenants ACTION for wrongful eviction, where the tenant is seeking to regain possession of the leasehold
S - SPECIFIC performance of a real property contract
P - PARTITION by one concurrent tenant against another
M - MORTGAGE foreclosures
E - EJECTMENT actions against trespassers
N - the tort of NUISANCE, to prevent the defendant from using her land in a manner that unreasonable interferes with the plaintiffs enjoyment of her land
BIN
Once a plaintiff has chosen venue, there are three grounds to change that venue, which can be found in a BIN
B - BAD venue was chosen by the plaintiff
I - a fair and IMPARTIAL trial cannot be had in the proper county chosen by the plaintiff
N - the proper county is simply to inconvenient for NECESSARY witnesses
SPARE RIBS
The SPARE RIBS ground for motion to dismiss can also be asserted under CPLR 3018 as affirmative defenses. SPARE RIBS under CPLR 3211(a)(5) does not include the 3018 affirmative defense of comparative negligence, fraud, or illegality
S - STATUTE of limitations
P - PAYMENT
A - ARBITRATION and AWARD
R - RELEASE was given by the plaintiff to the defendant
E - collateral ESTOPPEL
R - RES judicata
I - INFANCY or INCOMPETENCY of the defendant
B - the plaintiffs claim against the defendant was discharged in BANKRUPTCY
S - STATUTE of frauds where the court can easily determine the issue of assigned writing
LIPS
Whenever you are thinking of summary judgment, think of LIPS
L - the motion can be decided as a matter of LAW; and
I - there are no ISSUES of material fact to be litigated, except for damages or a CPLR 3211a issue; and
P - the court can grant PARTIAL summary judgment; and
S - the court can "SEARCH the record" but only on issues raised in the motion papers
LIAR
There are four provisional remedies in the CPLR - LIAR
L - LIS PENDENS (aka a notice of pendency) which warns third parties not to buy the real property or to issue a mortgage on the real property because of the plaintiffs claim to the real property
I - a preliminary INJUNCTION restraining a party pending the final outcome of a lawsuit
A - an order directing the sheriff to ATTACH a defendant's property within NY as security for payment of a final money judgment
R - a RECEIVER appointed by the court for the purpose of overseeing and preserving property involved in an equitable action
SLOB
The lis pendens is the only provisional remedy where the plaintiff is not required to be a SLOB
S - the SHERIFF is not involved; and
L - there is not court review of the plaintiffs LIKELIHOOD of success on the merits of the plaintiffs claims; and
O - no court ORDER is required; and
B - no BOND has to be posted by the plaintiff
LIE
A preliminary injunction will not be granted by the court unless the defendant can demonstrate by clear and convincing evidence LIE
L - the LIKELIHOOD of the success of the plaintiff on the merits of her claim. This requires a probability but not a certainty of the plaintiffs success; and
I - IRREPARABLE INJURY is occurring or will occur to the plaintiff unless the preliminary injunction is granted
E - EQUITIES when balanced by the court, clearly weigh in the plaintiffs favor
FIND CJ
Extraordinary circumstances must exist before a court will sign an order of attachment, FIND CJ
F - the defendant is a FOREIGN corporation not qualified to do business in NY
I - with the INTENT to defraud creditors, or frustrate the money judgment, the defendant has concealed or transferred her NY assets, or is about to do so
N - the defendant is a NON-DOMICILE residing outside the state
D - the defendant is a NY DOMICILE, or NY resident, who cannot be served despite diligent efforts to do so.
C - the plaintiff is a CRIME victim suing a CONVICTED felon
J - the plaintiff's cause of action is based on an out-of-state JUDGMENT that must first be confirmed by a NY state court before it can be enforced in a NY state court
COP
Before a court permits the use of LIAR, it must ensure that due process is satisfied by a COP
C - a showing by CLEAR and CONVINCING evidence that the plaintiff is likely to succeed and is entitled to the provisional remedy requested because of existing extraordinary circumstances
O - the ORDER must be issued by a judge
P - an immediate POST-SEIZURE hearing if LIAR was obtained ex parte.
3-D FFUN
Serious injury is defined as 3-D FFUN
D - DEATH
D - DISFIGUREMENT which a reasonable person would view as unattractive or the object of pity or scorn
D - DISMEMBERMENT
F - FRACTURE
F - loss of a FETUS proximately caused by the accident
U - medically determined, permanent loss of the plaintiff's USE of a body part, function or system
N - medically determined, NON-PERMANENT, loss that presented the plaintiff from engaging in her customary activities for 90 out of 180 days following the accident
SOME DIP
Generally civil cases are tried in the order in which the notice of issue and statement of readiness are filed, except CPLR 3403 gives a special trial preference to the following SOME DIP cases:
S - STATE or municipal agency, simply makes a motion for trial preference
O - any party OLDER than age 69
M - MEDICAL MALPRACTICE cases
E - ELECTION disputes
D - DESTITUTE plaintiff
I - IN the INTEREST of justice
P - PERSONAL injury case where the plaintiff's terminal illness was caused by the defendants tortous conduct
I'M RAW
A NY injured plaintiff continues to receive the common law benefits of joint and several liability in certain I'M Raw cases, but the NY plaintiff has the burden of pleading this exemption in a complaint and proving it at trial.
I - claims of INTENTIONAL tortous conduct
M - a co-defendant who is found MORE than 50% responsible for the plaintiffs injuries
R - any RECKLESS conduct forfeits the right to seek a limitation on joint and several liability
A - where the plaintiffs injuries were caused by the defendant's ownership, operation, or use of an AUTOMOBILE, motorcycle, or other motor vehicle.
W - WORKERS compensation cases
M.O.P. - Subject Matter Jurisdiction
M - MINIMUM CONTACTS with the State of NY
O - OPPORTUNITY for the defendant to be heard
P - the defendant must have been properly served with PROCESS
D.I.A.L. D.C. - Personal Jurisdiction
D - DOING BUSINESS which involves a non-domicile conducting purposefully continuous and systematic activity on a day to day basis
I - INSTATE SERVICE
A - serving the defendants NY AGENT within NY
L - LONG-ARM Jurisdiction
D - DOMICILE of NY when the plaintiff commences the action
C - a defendant CONSENTS to jurisdiction
CPLR 302(a)(3) plus D.E.E.R.
CONTEXT - LONG-ARM JURISDICTION (diaL dc)
CPLR 302(a)(3) is used when a non-domicile commits a tortous act outside of NY and the first effect of the tortous act experienced by the plaintiff is within the state of NY plus D.E.E.R.
D - defendant DERIVES "substantial revenues" from hoods used of consumed or from services rendered in NY
E - defendant ENGAGES in some persistent course of conduct within NY
E - the defendant should reasonably EXPECT (forseeability) that its tortous act would have a consequence in NY
R - the defendant REGULARLY does or solicits business in NY
DADA
CPLR 302(b) - in a matrimonial action, or in a proceeding in family court, where the plaintiff is seeking maintenance or child support, there exists personal jurisdiction over the non-domicile defendant provided DADA
D - NY was the last recent marital DOMICILE of the parties; or
A - the ABANDONMENT took place in NY; or
D - the claim for support accrued in a NY DECREE or under NY law which permits a NY paternity proceeding to be commenced on a non-domicile where the non-marital child was conceived in NY; or
A - the parties executed a SEPARATION AGREEMENT in NY
A SCAM
CPLR 3211(e) - Even though a defendant has no minimum contacts with NY, or was no properly served with process, the defendant may nevertheless consent to jurisdiction by A SCAM
A - serving an ANSWER and failing to include the mock jurisdictional answer, unless the defendant corrects the omission and amends the answer 'as a right' without going to court
S - STIPULATING to jurisdiction in 'open court' or in a signed writing
C - asserting an unrelated COUNTERCLAIM in the defendant answer
A - ASSERTING improper service of process in the defendants answer but failing to move for summary judgment in this issue within 60 days of serving the answer
M - by making any CPLR 3211(a) MOTIONS TO DISMISS, but failing to raise the MOP jurisdictional objections in that motion
REAM
RE = REASONABLE EXCUSE together with an
AM = AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT
AN
Who can serve a summons in NY? CPLR 2103(a)
AN = an ADULT, NON-PARTY
ALRAN
Who can serve outside the state? CPLR 313
ALRAN
A - an ATTORNEY admitted in that jurisdiction
L - look to the LAWS of that jurisdiction
RAN - a RESIDENT of NY, ADULT, NON-PARTY
CID'S Mail
Once process has been filed with the county clerk, then regardless of if the defendant was served inside or outside the state, service is proper only if made pursuant to one of the five proscribed methods of serving process in CPLR Article 3 (CID'S Mail)
C - COURT invented service (CPLR 308(5))
I - IN HAND delivery to the defendant (CPLR 308(1))
D - DUE DILIGENCE in attempting to first serve the defendant in hand or by serving a SAD person, and then nailing, mailing to the post office proof of service within 90 days (CPLR 308(4))
S - delivering process to a SAD person, then mailing a copy of process to the defendant, then filing proof of serving within 20 days (CPLR 308(2))
Mail - MAILING process to the defendant, but only if the defendant consents to such service (CPLR 312-a)
SAD Person
Person of SUITABLE AGE and DISCRETION
A MAC DOG
Service on a Corporation can be made only by in hand delivery to A MAC DOG corporate person anywhere she can be found (CPLR 311(a)(1))
A - ASSISTANT cashier (this refers to Chief Financial Officer - the person who handles finance)
M - MANAGING agent (as distinguished from a mere employee)
A - ANY AGENT AUTHORIZED to receive service (either expressly, impliedly, or by estoppel)
C - CASHIER (CFO)
D - DIRECTOR
O - OFFICER (President, VP, Secretary)
G - GENERAL agent
MAN
There are three ways for the defendant to formally appear in the action, MAN (CPLR 320(a))
M - by the defendant making a pre-answer MOTION that automatically extends the defendants time to answer (CPLR 3211 motion to dismiss or a CPLR 3024 corrective motion)
A - serving an ANSWER to the plaintiffs complaint
N - serving a one-page NOTICE of appearance, responding the the plaintiffs summons served without a complaint
IF
A crime victim has a 10 year SOL for certain specified serious crimes. If the defendant is convicted in the criminal court, then in a subsequent civil suit the crime victim can move for summary judgment on the liability issue based on the doctrine of collateral estoppel, provided IF.
I - there are IDENTICAL ISSUES in the criminal and civil cases
F - the party against whom collateral estoppel is being asserted previously had a FULL and FAIR opportunity to litigate that issue
SCARF CRIME
6 Years SOL
S - SPECIFIC performance of a contact, subject to the defense of latches
C - breach of CONTRACT actions
A - ACTIONS recognized by the courts and common law but where the legislature has not given that claim a statute of limitations
R - REFORMATION of a contract
F - FRAUD, deceit, or negligent misrepresentation, including fraud claims on contracts involving the sale of goods
C - CORPORATE derivative actions, where a shareholder on the corporations behalf sues a wrong doing corporate director or officer
R - RESCISSION of a contract
I - INDEMNIFICATION and contribution
M - MORTGAGE foreclosures
E - other EQUITABLE claims, such as unjust enrichment, constructive trust, a claim for an accounting or a claim for breach of fiduciary duty seeking equitable relief
SIIR M
The elements for fraud are SIIR M
S - the defendant's SCIENTER, the defendant 'knew' the statement was false
I - the lie was made with the INTENT to defraud or mislead the plaintiff
I - the plaintiff suffers economic INJURY because of the fraud
R - the plaintiff's REASONABLE RELIANCE on the statement, but in NY, if the fraudulent statement easily could have been verified by reasonable diligence, but it was not, then the plaintiff's reliance on the statement was not 'reasonable'
M - the defendant's statement involves a false statement of MATERIAL fact that induced the plaintiff into entering the contract
SHIFTS
There are certain 'badges' of fraud that are so commonly associated with fraudulent transfers that their presence gives rise to an inference of intent to defraud. SHIFTS
S - SECRETLY done
H - HASTILY done
I - INADEQUATE consideration to support the transfer
F - it was made to a FRIEND or FAMILY member
T - the TRANSFEROR continued to control the TRANSFERRED property
S - SCIENTER (knowledge) of the creditors claim and an inability to pay the claim after transfer
T-CUP
A claim for constructive trust requires four elements: T-CUP
T - TRANSFER of property or money; and
C - a CONFIDENTIAL relationship between the parties; and
U - UNJUST enrichment because of the transfer; and
P - a PROMISE and a breach of that PROMISE
A PAIN
In NY, the grounds for divorce are A PAIN (DRL 210)
A - ADULTERY
P - a spouse has been in PRISON for three consecutive years;
A - a spouse has ABANDONED the other spouse for at least one consecutive year preceding the plaintiffs claim;
I - cruel and INHUMANE treatment
N - NO-FAULT divorce
A SOFT RAIN
3 Years SOL
A - ACTIONS which did not exist at common law, but are solely the creation of a legislature, but it did not provide a SOL for that new law
S - STRICT products liability
O - misappropriation of a business OPPORTUNITY
F - breach of a FIDUCIARY duty
T - damages for a defendants TRESPASS on a plaintiff's real property
R - REPLEVIN or conversion
A - ANNULMENT of a marriage for fraud
I - tortous INTERFERENCE with another persons contract
N - NEGLIGENCE and malpractice by a professional, except medical malpractice
DIM
A product may be defective and unreasonably dangerous because of a DIM defect.
D - DEFECTIVELY DESIGNED when it left the manufacturers hands
I - INADEQUATE warnings
M - unintended MANUFACTURING flaw
-
- 1 / 42
-
Lernkarten
SOME DIP
Generally civil cases are tried in the order in which the notice of issue and statement of readiness are filed, except CPLR 3403 gives a special trial preference to the following SOME DIP cases:
S - STATE or municipal agency, simply makes a motion for trial preference
O - any party OLDER than age 69
M - MEDICAL MALPRACTICE cases
E - ELECTION disputes
D - DESTITUTE plaintiff
I - IN the INTEREST of justice
P - PERSONAL injury case where the plaintiff's terminal illness was caused by the defendants tortous conduct
I'M RAW
A NY injured plaintiff continues to receive the common law benefits of joint and several liability in certain I'M Raw cases, but the NY plaintiff has the burden of pleading this exemption in a complaint and proving it at trial.
I - claims of INTENTIONAL tortous conduct
M - a co-defendant who is found MORE than 50% responsible for the plaintiffs injuries
R - any RECKLESS conduct forfeits the right to seek a limitation on joint and several liability
A - where the plaintiffs injuries were caused by the defendant's ownership, operation, or use of an AUTOMOBILE, motorcycle, or other motor vehicle.
W - WORKERS compensation cases