Evolutionsbiologie
ETH Zürich
ETH Zürich
-
- 1 / 230
-
Cartes-fiches
Conditions favoring reciprocal altruism
1. Stable group associations allwoing repeated interactions among same individuals 2. many within-lifetime interaction opportunities 3. good memories 4. potential altruists interacting in symmetrical situations; hard to study in nature: interacting kin-selection, logistical limitations
Reciprocal altruism explaining human cooperation
Intelligent, strong memory; Small groups of repeatedly-interacting individuals; Disivion of labor, task specialization; Good at detecting cheaters and punishment of them
Blood sharing in Vampire bats
Roost together during day; Data on who roosted with who and relatedness amongst them; Blood meal regurgitation is altruistic because limiting; regurgitation preferred to kin and non-kin they often roost with; bats most likely receive food from those to whom they had previously given
Life history: an example
The perfect organism would: be born fertile, constantly make lot of healthy offspring, live forever; BUT physical limits to energy and resource uptake, biological processes take time
Trade off
Biological constraint limiting possible combinations of traits; Natural selection favors combinations of traits that maximize lifetime reproductive success
Why do organisms age and die?
Three possibilites: 1. Biological constraint 2. Mutation accumulation 3. Antagonistic pleiotropy
Biological constraint
Organisms have reached the limit of what's possible; Evidence against: artificial selection can increase life span, mutations increasing life time, human demographics
Evidence for mutation accumulation
Inbreeding depression caused by deleterious recessives, selection is weaker on late acting alleles => inbreeding depression should increase with age; Senescence mutations should be neutral and accumulate by drift; Senescence rate similar in small vs. large populations => decline in natural longevity
Antagonistic pleiotropy
Pleiotropy: Mutation having multiple effects; Antagonistic: enhances a trait and harms another; Mutations enhancing reproduction early in life hasten senescence; Evidence: flies with mutations in methuselah gene live longer but have reduced lifetime reproductive success, birds breeding early in life are hindered at late-life reproduction but have higher overall lifetime repro
Medicine & Evolution
1854 Cholera epidemic traced to water pump; 2002 14.7 mil. individuals die due to infectious organisms, 26% of all deaths
Microbes
Invisible to the naked eye; Large populations size; High population mutation rates; Reproduce quickly => Very rapid evolution, Flu-vaccines are being re-desgined every year
Flu evolution
More than occasional annoyance; Flu evolution being tracked by sequencing frozen samples; Current ancestors of future surviving lineages can be predicted
High pandemic risk potential: bird flu A/ H7N9
Small outbreak of bird flu in China 2013; Apathogenic in birds (reservoir hosts), Zoonosis (animal => human infections); Dangerous potential because: Easier transmission to humans than 2004 outbreak, high death toll, evidence for transmission in ferrets, no immunity acquired!!!
Evolutionary issues in infectious disease
Resistance to antibiotics and antivirals, Evolution of pathogen virulence, Emerging pathogens; Is fever good for you?
Antibiotics history
1875: Penicillium fungi; 1895: cured typhoid fever with penicillium; 1939: Commercial antibiotics production
Germs evolve resistance
Infections in hospitals: Nosocomial infections (7% of all hospital patients...); 70% of bacteria causing hospital infections are resistant to at least one commonly used antibiotic; Some are resistant to ALL...
Halting the evolution of antibiotic resistance
Antibiotic resistance is costly; Ex: In Iceland, frequency of resistant Pneumococcus declined after reduction on prescribtion for penicillin antibiotics
Has antibiotic resistance always a fitness cost?
Experimantal evolution with E. coli; resistant bacteria evolve in absence of antibiotics => mutations; Competition between sensitive and resistant bacteria; Ancestral background: resistance is costly, evolved background: resistant bacteria are fitter; Bacteria evolved to compensate for initial cost of resistance
Antibiotic resistance won't go away if we stop using antibiotics => avoid resistance in the first place
Other forms of resistance evolution
Agricultural: Evolution of resistance to fungicides and insecticides; HIV rapidly evolves resistance to antiviral therapy
Why do pathogens harm their hosts?
Pathogens rely on hosts to complete life cycle, so why do they kill?; Virulence = damage to hosts caused by infection; Some pathogens very harmful, some very mild
Hypotheses on diversity of pathogens
Life history trade-offs between virulence and infectious transmission; Short-sighted evolution within hosts; Coincidental evolution hypothesis
Virulence trade-offs
Pathogens balance within-host reproduction to maximize a life history trade off between infectious transmission and host survival; Evidence: When viruses were given more room for horizontal transmission, the viruses evolved higher virulence and higher reproductive rates, but less opportunity for host switch leads to less virulence
Short-sighted evolution
Virulence not adaptive for pathogen in the longe run, short-sighted evolution within hosts; Evidence: Some pathogens don't cause harm during their normal life cycle, the yonly make people sick when they infect nervous tissue, but they don't get transmitted to new hosts
So why harming hosts?
Different pathigens = different reasons; General issue: Looking for general principles but always work within a specific system; Virulence evolution is an active research area, there's no consensus yet
Emerging infectious disease
Phylogenetics allows understanding of source of diseases like SARS, Ebola; Tracking epidemics; Understanding why HIV makes some primate species sick, others not
Is fever good for you?
Host defense mechanism? Higher temperature => pathogens reproduce slower, immune system faster?
Behavioral fever in ectothermal animals: desert iguanas
Response to infection with bacteria, iguanas move to warmer places and raise their body temperature; When they're not allowed to choose temperature, survivability is higher in higher temperature; Fever is an adaptive response not imposed by bacteria
Fever in Endotherms
Study on bacteria infected vs. control rats with implanted cooling devices; Infected rats with cooled brain: very high-fever, normal metabolism => low survival; Infected rats with cooled spinal cord: normal body temperature, high metabolism => higher survival; Infected rats non-cooled: Higher fever => lower survival, higher metabolism => higher survival
Fever in humans
Helps iguanas, verdict is still out for humans...; Anti-fever medication might prolong illness by affecting immune system; High fevers can however cause permanent neurological damage; Fever is a high cost; Some pathogens are better adapted to high temperature than others, fever effects differ with pathogen type
Adaption and human disease: breast cancer
Most common form of invasive cancer in women worldwide; Caused by genes, environment or both? If genetic why didn't we purge deleterious breats cancer alleles? If environmentally induced, why did we not evolve resistance to stress?
FACTS on breast cancer
First strong increase in late 19th century (parallel to increasing hygiene & antibiotics); Secong strong incrase in 1970s; 12% of women will develop breast cancer; 50% of women which carry a deleterious allele of a gene will develop cancer by age 70
Two hypotheses on breast cancer
1. Pathogens coevolve with human population? 2. Breast cancer a civilization disease?
Breast cancer caused by pathogens
House mice: A Virus that causes breast cancer; Host jump to humans causes human disease?; High incidence of sequences similiar to the virus in cancerous breat tissue; Higher breast cancer incidence in areas populated by house mouse species heavily infested with the virus; Evidence BUT not conclusive... No actual virus particles found in cancerous breast tissue
Breast cancer as a civilization disease
Menstruation: breast tissue divides => more mutations; Modern women menstruate monthly wheras the Dogon women of Mali don't; Dogon women only have 100 cycles/life wheras modern women have >300 cycles; Breast cancer only 0.67%, 12.5% worldwide!!!
How to define species?
Smallest evolutionary independent unit; Independent evolution when selection, migration, drift and mutation operate seperately; Evolution consists of allele frequency changes; Core of species distinction is lack of gene flow
Morphospecies Concept
Morphological similarity is central criterion; Pros: broad apllicability, including extinct and asexual species; Cons: hard to standarize trait definitions across scientists, hard wehen phenotypes are difficult to see
Biological species concept (BSC)
Reproductive isolation is central criterion; Lack of regular hybridization or lack of fertile offspring thereof; Pros: confirms lack of gene flow; Cons: difficult to apply sometimes, non-applicalble to asexuals, extinct species
Phylogenetic species concept (PSC)
Defining the smallest monophyletic group that can be distinguished from other monophyletic groups; Monophyly: lineages containing all known descendants of common ancestor; Pros: applies to all organisms; Cons: labor intensive, aters radically current classifications and greatly increasing number of species
Applying multiple species concepts
Marine crustacean copepods first only distinguished in one species; PSC and BSC resulted in at least 8 different geographically distinct species
Classical view of speciation
Isolation => divergence => secondary contact